It’s officially the holiday season which means it’s also baking season! And if you’re going to bake something to enjoy at Thanksgiving dinner, a Christmas party, or even for New Year’s Eve, a good holiday pie recipe is hard to beat!
Love a creamy, classic pumpkin pie? We’ve got a few variations to choose from, from traditional to cheesecake and more! And if apple is more your flavor, how about a caramel apple pie? Mini pies? Or a deepdish apple cranberry concoction? Yum.
We’ve got your traditional holiday pies, your non-traditional holiday pies (You can totally serve Key Lime Pie at Thanksgiving if you want!), even some pies for those with dietary restrictions. They’re arranged by category, starting with apple pies and working down through fruit pies, chocolate pies, pecan pies, etc.!
Check out our collection of 70+ holiday pie recipes below and let us know which one(s) you’ll be making this year!
70+ Holiday Pie Recipes
Every Holiday Pie Recipe You Could Need
From pumpkin pie to apple pie and every pie in between, these are the holiday pie recipes to make this year!
It's hard to beat a good ol' apple pie! From classic recipes to ones with a twist (like caramel, cranberry, or cheese!), if apple pie needs a place on the table, we've found some delicious recipes for you to choose from!
Our love affair with fall desserts continues with this salted maple caramel apple pie recipe that you are sure to FREAK out over. It’s a spin on a more traditional apple pie that will have you wondering why it took you so long to start drizzling homemade salted maple caramel sauce on ALL of the apple things.
Mini Walnut Apple Pies, an easy recipe for mini apple pies loaded with crunchy walnuts that is perfect for Thanksgiving dessert and holiday parties. These mini muffin tin apple pies are also great to make ahead and freeze!
This Apple Pie from Scratch is perfect for Thanksgiving and fall baking! The apple pie is chock full of beautifully spiced apples and has a wonderfully flaky, flavorful double-crust using chef techniques I’m sharing with you!
As part of our air fryer pie series, air fryer apple pie is perfect for air fryer cooking. Load it with your favourite seasonal apples, add our homemade air fryer pie crust and you will achieve an amazing golden crispy crusted apple pie in the air fryer.
Vanilla Pear Pie has a heavenly flavor and aroma. A hint of vanilla bean enhances but doesn’t overwhelm the delicate flavor of fresh pears. Move over Apple Pie, this just might become your favorite new holiday dessert.
This Mexican Chocolate Pie is creamy sweet and slightly spicy. It takes just 10 minutes to prep and only about an hour to finish including prep, baking, decoration and clean up.
It's not a holiday gathering unless there's a pumpkin pie, right? We've got your classic recipes, but a few fun twists too. How about a Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake? Mini pies? Or one you can make in your air fryer? We've got them all!
Easy to follow ways to make pumpkin pie in the air fryer. Our air fryer version of homemade pumpkin pie is delicious and includes homemade air fryer pie crust. Perfect for either the air fryer or the air fryer oven.
My mom has always made the BEST pumpkin pie and she would never tell me her secret! Finally - at age 70 - she gave it up! The one secret ingredient that makes her pumpkin pie better than anybody else's! It's so easy and mixes up in minutes!
Sunflower Seed Pie is sure to be a crowd pleaser! This nut free pie is a great alternative to pecan pie. Easy to make in a few simple steps this unique sunflower pie is delicious and perfect for the Thanksgiving table.
You won’t feel like you’re missing out when with this easy Gluten Free Crustless Pumpkin Pie. Simple to make, and full of flavor, this pie will become the favorite of everyone, whether they have to avoid gluten or not.
Swapping out the corn syrup for pure maple syrup in this Gluten-Free Pecan Pie adds to the depth and richness of the pie’s flavor. Maple syrup is so amazing on its own, but when used in pecan pie, it’s downright fabulous.
Jamie loves a little black dress, chips and salsa, and is obsessed with subscription boxes. She tries to maintain an air of sophisticated city life while actually living next to a wheat field. Or is it alfalfa? Corn? She doesn’t know. You can find her blogging about style and shopping at JK Style. She lives in rural Oklahoma with her husband and baby boy.
Privacy & Cookies Policy
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.