Skip to Content

What’s Your Favorite Mascara? 8 Women Share Their Favorites

Love this? Share it!

We asked some of our contributors the ultimate question: What’s your favorite mascara? We got all kinds of responses, maybe one of these brands will be the perfect fit for you!

Whats your favorite mascara? We had eight real women share their favorites with us!

Revlon Grow Luscious in Brown-Black (Jessica)

revlon grow luscious

I loved it for a long time because it doesn’t smudge or flake. But I am always looking for something that makes my baby translucent lashes pop. I’m kind of “over” this one, it’s just a safety net for me now. – Jessica


It depends! (Brenna)

It really varies what mascara I use. I am not a picky makeup girl and I really like trying new stuff, so I base my mascara decisions on what is on sale, what packaging is the cutest, the color of the mascara tube and if it has certain ingredients that I am allergic too. (The last reason obviously being the most important!) – Brenna


Urban Decay Perversion (Sara)

urban decay perversion

It’s amazing but a little messy to take off. I also use Younique fiber lashes. We have a love/hate relationship because while they are great, I don’t use the fibers every day and it took me about 5-7 times of applying them before I got the hang of it. (You can read Sara’s review of Urban Decay Mascara here.) – Sara


Maybelline Falsies (Anna Jane)

maybelline falsies

My new favorite mascara. I used Maybelline Great Lash for ages but needed a change. It goes on really well and I feel awesome when I wear it. – Anna Jane


Anything new! (Amanda)

Whatever I see that’s new. L’Oreal discontinued my favorite mascara years ago and I’ve never found a replacement. I’m always open to suggestions! -Amanda


L’Oreal Voluminous Butterfly (Annie)

loreal voluminous

Such a hot button topic for makeup artists. Ha. I love drug store mascaras! I love anything L’Oreal voluminous but my favorite right now is the L’Oreal Voluminous Butterfly! Always choose black mascara to make your eyes pop with minimal effort. – Annie


Marc Jacobs Velvet Noir Major Volume Mascara (Jamie)

My lashes are decently long but Marc Jacobs Velvet Noir Major Volume Mascara finally gives me the volume I want! I can use a couple of coats for a more natural look or layer it on for more drama! – Jamie


Open to suggestions (Dara)

I have long eyelashes so I am always looking for one that makes my lashes darker but doesn’t get all over my face. Right now I am using Clinique’s Naturally Glossy, but I am open to suggestions. – Dara

Tell us! What’s your favorite mascara??

Originally published February 18, 2016

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Julia Arnold

Wednesday 3rd of May 2017

LOVE all these suggestions. L'Oreal discontinued my favorite a couple of years ago too! I love the newish Cover Girl Plumpify.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.